Here's my itinerary- please poke holes in it where needed.
Anything marked with ?? is drop-able if time is short.
Sept. 26 Party Itinerary
3:15 Depart from Poly for Magic Kingdom
3:45-4:00 Enter, get wristbands
4:15 Use FPs for 7DMT (3:20-4:20)
4:30-6:00 Tag Team: Wait for Jack & Sally meet
Tag Team: Take turns with DW using FPs for Peter Pan (4:25-5:25)
6:15-6:35 Use FPs for BTMRR (5:30-6:30)
6:40-7:00 Ride PotC
7:15-7:30 Watch Cadaver Dans
7:30-8:00 Haunted Mansion
8:00-8:20 ?? ToT (Riverboat, Heritage House) ??
8:20 Get spot on Main Street for Parade
8:25-9:00 Tag Team: Get SotMK card, buy merchandise
9:15 Parade
9:45-10:15 Don't move
10:15 Hallowishes
10:35-10:55 Meet Lotso Huggin' Bear
11:00-11:15 Ride Buzz Lightyear
11:15-11:30 ToT (Stitch, CoP, Space Mtn)
11:30-11:45 Monsters Dance Party
11:45-??:?? ?? If 7 Dwarfs line isn't cut off, hop in it ??
12:00 Hocus Pocus
So we had a fantastic time at the party Tuesday night! It was our first party so I don't have anything to compare it to, but it certainly felt crowded around the Hub and most of Adventureland. From the best of my memory, here's how our night went:
3:30: Lined up for entrance. They opened it up right about 3:40.
3:45: Went through bypass, got some pictures and treat bags
3:55-4:20: used Fast passes to ride 7dmt and Peter Pan
4:30: Got in line for Jack and Sally. It was already almost to the Adventureland Bridge
6:20: Finished with Jack and Sally
6:35: Got in line for PotC
7:00: Finished with PotC, got in line for ToT station at Tiki room. This was probably a mistake, it took a while to go through and we ended up getting plenty of candy later in the night.
7:15-7:30: Went through line to get Oogie Boogie popcorn bucket.
7:45: Back to Main Street to get Sorcerers cards, also went back through the bypass
8:00: Buzz Lightyear ride
8:10-8:25: Lotso meet
8:25-8:35: We hit the Carousel of Progress ToT station, then a few minutes at the Monsters dance party
8:40: Snagged a parade spot on Main Street right in front of the Starbucks. We were too late for a curb spot, but were second row and had a great view
One thing to keep in mind if you have little ones is that after the Headless Horseman comes through at 9:15, you've still got a good 15-20 minutes of waiting for the parade. If you're closer to the train station you at least get some entertainment from the Zootopia crew, but our kids were getting pretty restless by the time the parade arrived.
10:00: Right after parade ended, went and grabbed a fireworks viewing spot in the Hub area in front of Casey's. This wasn't too hard during the shuffle post-parade, The Hallowishes fireworks were amazing!
10:30-11:10: Did Haunted mansion ride. Was a good 20 minute wait, but the atmosphere around the ride was really well done. Was entertained by the butler for a while there as well.
11:15-11:25: Hit the Philharmagic ToT station. Really enjoyed how they were playing old Mickey haunted house cartoons on the big screen, my boys (5 & 6) were cracking up and would have sat in there a lot longer if I'd let us. DW went to meet Ducks during this, was about a 20 minute wait.
11:30: Met up with DW at 7 Dwarves, which was only a 15 minute wait. Switched off with DW to ToT with boys at Pete's Sideshow. If you're looking to max out your candy haul, hitting this at the end of the night is a good bet. There was no wait, and the girls working in there were just pouring candy into the boys' bags.
11:45: Bought our Halloween merch at Big Top, then headed to Dumbo for a few walk-on rides to close out the night. On our way out we caught some of the final Hocus Pocus show. The projections during this show looked really good, especially during Oogie Boogie part.
Overall, it was a full and very fun time!